Claire VS Jill

Who would win in a cat fight?






Edit: Poll added

Jill, former member of Delta Force, probably the most elite special operations unit in the world, vs Claire, a college student?

You're kidding, right? In fact, I hope to Zeus that you're trolling...

I think they are both very strong characters.

Oh god I can't stop laughing xD

"She is strong willfg cmc wiiplcl eglurny:"

Mass Distraction wrote:

Oh god I can't stop laughing xD

"She is strong willfg cmc wiiplcl eglurny:"

I know right? lol I couldn't find the normal one.

Claire because she has a better ass. *troll face*

Jill would probably win due to her training and everything, but I would personally be rooting for Claire.

Usually Jill, but not this new weirdo face she's got. I don't like it, I don't like it one bit.

Spike991 wrote:

Usually Jill, but not this new weirdo face she's got. I don't like it, I don't like it one bit.

I think she looks cute.
But her new appearance gives off this Final Fantasy vibe.

Jill defiantly

ChrisSherry wrote:

I think they are both very strong characters.

So? As I said, Jill is a former Delta shooter, so she would win. It's not even a debate.

ChrisSherry wrote:

I think they are both very strong characters.

Definitely, But i am still Claire Redfield aaaalllll the waaaaaay.

ChrisSherry wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

Usually Jill, but not this new weirdo face she's got. I don't like it, I don't like it one bit.

I think she looks cute.
But her new appearance gives off this Final Fantasy vibe.

IDK what it is...it just looks different. Maybe they just squished her face some...?

Spike991 wrote:

ChrisSherry wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

Usually Jill, but not this new weirdo face she's got. I don't like it, I don't like it one bit.

I think she looks cute.
But her new appearance gives off this Final Fantasy vibe.

IDK what it is...it just looks different. Maybe they just squished her face some...?

her face model since remake was julia voth. But they stopped using her after RE5.


. And I think its a tie between claire and jill, i mean, claire did get trained by Chris, and seeing as they are probably orphans, and chris having to watch out for her, he taught her everything he knew and more. Plus claires probably got street smarts, she looks like shes a member of the hells angels when she gets to raccoon city. Probably badass biker chick with military training!so she can at least give jill a run for her money.

00biohazard wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

ChrisSherry wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

Usually Jill, but not this new weirdo face she's got. I don't like it, I don't like it one bit.

I think she looks cute.
But her new appearance gives off this Final Fantasy vibe.

IDK what it is...it just looks different. Maybe they just squished her face some...?

her face model since remake was julia voth. But they stopped using her after RE5.

Yeah I know who Julia Voth is, more than anyone.

But I didn't realize they stopped using her...maybe they just did that for RER for some reason?

I know that I'm gonna hate that if this is a permaneant change...

Spike991 wrote:

00biohazard wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

ChrisSherry wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

Usually Jill, but not this new weirdo face she's got. I don't like it, I don't like it one bit.

I think she looks cute.
But her new appearance gives off this Final Fantasy vibe.

IDK what it is...it just looks different. Maybe they just squished her face some...?

her face model since remake was julia voth. But they stopped using her after RE5.

Yeah I know who Julia Voth is, more than anyone.

But I didn't realize they stopped using her...maybe they just did that for RER for some reason?

I know that I'm gonna hate that if this is a permaneant change...

Its two games in a row now, RER and ORC. Im sorry to say, but your probably gonna have to get used to it. I know. I was sad too.

00biohazard wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

00biohazard wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

ChrisSherry wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

Usually Jill, but not this new weirdo face she's got. I don't like it, I don't like it one bit.

I think she looks cute.
But her new appearance gives off this Final Fantasy vibe.

IDK what it is...it just looks different. Maybe they just squished her face some...?

her face model since remake was julia voth. But they stopped using her after RE5.

Yeah I know who Julia Voth is, more than anyone.

But I didn't realize they stopped using her...maybe they just did that for RER for some reason?

I know that I'm gonna hate that if this is a permaneant change...

Its two games in a row now, RER and ORC. Im sorry to say, but your probably gonna have to get used to it. I know. I was sad too.

Yeah, it's really unfortunate. One of my friends told me she got pissed that they were making money off her face and she didn't want them using it anymore.

@Ghost Leader: You can't argue with them using logic. It doesn't apply to them.

00biohazard wrote:

so she can at least give jill a run for her money.

I have to reiterate: Delta Force is probably the most elite Special Operations unit in the world, and Jill is a former member. This unit, in conjunction with CIA SAD, defeated the Iraqi army in 2003 long before the oh-so-frequently publicized and televised ground war had even officially begun. The Taliban in Afghanistan met a similar fate two years earlier.

Claire is a college girl with a little bit of self-defense training.

Do all of you Claire fans not comprehend the huge gap here?

Ghost Leader wrote:

00biohazard wrote:

so she can at least give jill a run for her money.

I have to reiterate: Delta Force is probably the most elite Special Operations unit in the world, and Jill is a former member. This unit, in conjunction with CIA SAD, defeated the Iraqi army in 2003 long before the oh-so-frequently publicized and televised ground war had even officially begun. The Taliban in Afghanistan met a similar fate two years earlier.

Claire is a college girl with a little bit of self-defense training.

Do all of you Claire fans not comprehend the huge gap here?

I know that. Claire is a college student who loved motorcycles she had been undergo training by her brother, Chris. And she had the same ability as Jill, lockpicking. There is a lot of differences in them. But as i said. I stay and ill go for Claire Redfield still.

Ghost Leader wrote:

00biohazard wrote:

so she can at least give jill a run for her money.

I have to reiterate: Delta Force is probably the most elite Special Operations unit in the world, and Jill is a former member. This unit, in conjunction with CIA SAD, defeated the Iraqi army in 2003 long before the oh-so-frequently publicized and televised ground war had even officially begun. The Taliban in Afghanistan met a similar fate two years earlier.

Claire is a college girl with a little bit of self-defense training.

Do all of you Claire fans not comprehend the huge gap here?

I know that. Claire is a college student who loved motorcycles she had been undergo training by her brother, Chris. And she had the same ability as Jill, lockpicking. There is a lot of differences in them. But as i said. I stay and ill go for Claire Redfield still.

Miss Claire Redfield wrote:

Ghost Leader wrote:

00biohazard wrote:

so she can at least give jill a run for her money.

I have to reiterate: Delta Force is probably the most elite Special Operations unit in the world, and Jill is a former member. This unit, in conjunction with CIA SAD, defeated the Iraqi army in 2003 long before the oh-so-frequently publicized and televised ground war had even officially begun. The Taliban in Afghanistan met a similar fate two years earlier.

Claire is a college girl with a little bit of self-defense training.

Do all of you Claire fans not comprehend the huge gap here?

I know that. Claire is a college student who loved motorcycles she had been undergo training by her brother, Chris. And she had the same ability as Jill, lockpicking. There is a lot of differences in them. But as i said. I stay and ill go for Claire Redfield still.

What Chris might have taught her, I can guarantee you Jill has been extensively trained far beyond that.

Ghost Leader wrote:

Miss Claire Redfield wrote:

Ghost Leader wrote:

00biohazard wrote:

so she can at least give jill a run for her money.

I have to reiterate: Delta Force is probably the most elite Special Operations unit in the world, and Jill is a former member. This unit, in conjunction with CIA SAD, defeated the Iraqi army in 2003 long before the oh-so-frequently publicized and televised ground war had even officially begun. The Taliban in Afghanistan met a similar fate two years earlier.

Claire is a college girl with a little bit of self-defense training.

Do all of you Claire fans not comprehend the huge gap here?

I know that. Claire is a college student who loved motorcycles she had been undergo training by her brother, Chris. And she had the same ability as Jill, lockpicking. There is a lot of differences in them. But as i said. I stay and ill go for Claire Redfield still.

What Chris might have taught her, I can guarantee you Jill has been extensively trained far beyond that.

Very well said.

Mercy wrote:

00biohazard wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

00biohazard wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

ChrisSherry wrote:

Spike991 wrote:

Usually Jill, but not this new weirdo face she's got. I don't like it, I don't like it one bit.

I think she looks cute.
But her new appearance gives off this Final Fantasy vibe.

IDK what it is...it just looks different. Maybe they just squished her face some...?

her face model since remake was julia voth. But they stopped using her after RE5.

Yeah I know who Julia Voth is, more than anyone.

But I didn't realize they stopped using her...maybe they just did that for RER for some reason?

I know that I'm gonna hate that if this is a permaneant change...

Its two games in a row now, RER and ORC. Im sorry to say, but your probably gonna have to get used to it. I know. I was sad too.

Yeah, it's really unfortunate. One of my friends told me she got pissed that they were making money off her face and she didn't want them using it anymore.

@Ghost Leader: You can't argue with them using logic. It doesn't apply to them.

Dammit really? She seemed happy with them using her...I guess. I saw an interview that she had done.

I mean RER is a handheld game, and ORC is like a side thing, so I'm not gonna give up just yet.

Ghost Leader wrote:

Miss Claire Redfield wrote:

Ghost Leader wrote:

00biohazard wrote:

so she can at least give jill a run for her money.

I have to reiterate: Delta Force is probably the most elite Special Operations unit in the world, and Jill is a former member. This unit, in conjunction with CIA SAD, defeated the Iraqi army in 2003 long before the oh-so-frequently publicized and televised ground war had even officially begun. The Taliban in Afghanistan met a similar fate two years earlier.

Claire is a college girl with a little bit of self-defense training.

Do all of you Claire fans not comprehend the huge gap here?

I know that. Claire is a college student who loved motorcycles she had been undergo training by her brother, Chris. And she had the same ability as Jill, lockpicking. There is a lot of differences in them. But as i said. I stay and ill go for Claire Redfield still.

What Chris might have taught her, I can guarantee you Jill has been extensively trained far beyond that.

Ghost, I'm telling you, logic doesn't apply.

@Spike Well don't take what I said for fact, this is just word of mouth. But remember what Jill's face looked like in the 2010 trailer for Revelations? She looked like a horse. If they used Chris's same face why not Voth's? why wouldn't they?

Jill might have had lots of training.
But both Jill and Claire survived quite a lot through out the years.
They both survived RC, and with Claire only being a Collage, I think counts for something.
Also, who knows what Claire has done over the years... she could have gone through training as well.
In the RE5 viral campaign video titled "Claire"... it shows them training together.

Which probably isn't canon. However, something like that could be possible.
I think it would be rather cool if Claire joined the B.S.A.A.


But in the end, I guess if would really on depend on what Capcom would want if Claire and Jill ever went against each other...